The question asks which combination of tests would be most appropriate to include in the strategy for optimal detection in a workflow system using multiple ML models.

Pairwise testing of combinations (I): This method is useful for testing interactions between different components in the workflow to ensure they work well together, identifying potential issues in the integration.

Testing each individual model for accuracy (II): Ensuring that each model in the workflow performs accurately on its own is crucial before integrating them into a combined workflow.

A/B testing of different sequences of models (III): This involves comparing different sequences to determine which configuration yields the best results. While useful, it might not be as fundamental as pairwise and individual accuracy testing in the initial stages.

References:

ISTQB CT-AI Syllabus Section 9.2 on Pairwise Testing and Section 9.3 on Testing ML Models emphasize the importance of testing interactions and individual model accuracy in complex ML workflows.

Prevalence Rate and Model Performance:

The cancer detection system being developed by "Splendid Healthcare" needs to account for the fact that the type of cancer has a 2% prevalence rate in the population. This indicates that the dataset is highly imbalanced with far fewer positive (cancer) cases compared to negative (normal) cases.

Importance of Recall:

Recall, also known as sensitivity or true positive rate, measures the proportion of actual positive cases that are correctly identified by the model. In medical diagnosis, especially cancer detection, recall is critical because missing a positive case (false negative) could have severe consequences for the patient. Therefore, maximizing recall ensures that most, if not all, cancer cases are detected.

Importance of Precision:

Precision measures the proportion of predicted positive cases that are actually positive. High precision reduces the number of false positives, meaning fewer people will be incorrectly diagnosed with cancer. This is also important to avoid unnecessary anxiety and further invasive testing for those who do not have the disease.

Balancing Recall and Precision:

In scenarios where both false negatives and false positives have significant consequences, it is crucial to balance recall and precision. This balance ensures that the model is not only good at detecting positive cases but also accurate in its predictions, reducing both types of errors.

Accuracy and Specificity:

While accuracy (the proportion of total correct predictions) is important, it can be misleading in imbalanced datasets. In this case, high accuracy could simply result from the model predicting the majority class (normal) correctly. Specificity (true negative rate) is also important, but for a cancer detection system, recall and precision take precedence to ensure positive cases are correctly and accurately identified.

Conclusion:

Therefore, for a cancer detection system with a low prevalence rate, maximizing both recall and precision is crucial to ensure effective and accurate detection of cancer cases.

The question asks which test is least likely to be performed during the ML model testing phase. Let's consider each option:

Testing the accuracy of the classification model (A): Accuracy testing is a fundamental part of the ML model testing phase. It ensures that the model correctly classifies the data as intended and meets the required performance metrics.

Testing the API of the service powered by the ML model (B): Testing the API is crucial, especially if the ML model is deployed as part of a service. This ensures that the service integrates well with other systems and that the API performs as expected.

Testing the speed of the training of the model (C): This is least likely to be part of the ML model testing phase. The speed of training is more relevant during the development phase when optimizing and tuning the model. During testing, the focus is more on the model's performance and behavior rather than how quickly it was trained.

Testing the speed of the prediction by the model (D): Testing the speed of prediction is important to ensure that the model meets performance requirements in a production environment, especially for real-time applications.

References:

ISTQB CT-AI Syllabus Section 3.2 on ML Workflow and Section 5 on ML Functional Performance Metrics discuss the focus of testing during the model testing phase, which includes accuracy and prediction speed but not the training speed.

A. Regression

Regression is used to predict a continuous value and is not suitable for grouping people based on similar tastes.

B. Association

Association is used to find relationships between variables in large datasets, often in the form of rules (e.g., market basket analysis). It does not directly group individuals but identifies patterns of co-occurrence.

C. Clustering

Clustering is an unsupervised learning method used to group similar data points based on their features. It is ideal for identifying groups of people with similar tastes without prior knowledge of the group labels. This technique will help the company segment its customer base effectively.

D. Classification

Classification is a supervised learning method used to categorize data points into predefined classes. It requires labeled data for training, which is not the case here as we want to identify groups without predefined labels.

Therefore, the correct answer isCbecause clustering is the most suitable method for grouping people with similar tastes for targeted product marketing​​.

Testing Autonomy:Testing for human handover when it should not be relinquishing control is the least appropriate because it contradicts the very definition of autonomous systems. The other tests are relevant to ensuring smooth operation and transitions between human and AI control.

Reference:ISTQB_CT-AI_Syllabus_v1.0, Sections on Testing Autonomous AI-Based Systems and Testing for Human-AI Interaction​​​​. ​

To calculate the accuracy, recall, and specificity from the confusion matrix provided, we use the following formulas:

Confusion Matrix:

Actually Rotten: 45 (True Positive), 8 (False Positive)

Actually Fresh: 5 (False Negative), 42 (True Negative)

Accuracy:

Accuracy is the proportion of true results (both true positives and true negatives) in the total population.

Formula: Accuracy=TP+TNTP+TN+FP+FN\text{Accuracy} = \frac{TP + TN}{TP + TN + FP + FN}Accuracy=TP+TN+FP+FNTP+TN​

Calculation: Accuracy=45+4245+42+8+5=87100=0.87\text{Accuracy} = \frac{45 + 42}{45 + 42 + 8 + 5} = \frac{87}{100} = 0.87Accuracy=45+42+8+545+42​=10087​=0.87

Recall (Sensitivity):

Recall is the proportion of true positive results in the total actual positives.

Formula: Recall=TPTP+FN\text{Recall} = \frac{TP}{TP + FN}Recall=TP+FNTP​

Calculation: Recall=4545+5=4550=0.9\text{Recall} = \frac{45}{45 + 5} = \frac{45}{50} = 0.9Recall=45+545​=5045​=0.9

Specificity:

Specificity is the proportion of true negative results in the total actual negatives.

Formula: Specificity=TNTN+FP\text{Specificity} = \frac{TN}{TN + FP}Specificity=TN+FPTN​

Calculation: Specificity=4242+8=4250=0.84\text{Specificity} = \frac{42}{42 + 8} = \frac{42}{50} = 0.84Specificity=42+842​=5042​=0.84

Therefore, the correct combinations of accuracy, recall, and specificity are 0.87, 0.9, and 0.84 respectively.

References:

ISTQB CT-AI Syllabus, Section 5.1, Confusion Matrix, provides detailed formulas and explanations for calculating various metrics including accuracy, recall, and specificity.

"ML Functional Performance Metrics" (ISTQB CT-AI Syllabus, Section 5).

A. 64-bit CPUs.

While 64-bit CPUs are essential for handling large amounts of memory and performing complex computations, they are not specifically optimized for the types of operations commonly used in machine learning.

B. Hardware supporting fast matrix multiplication.

Matrix multiplication is a fundamental operation in many machine learning algorithms, especially in neural networks and deep learning. Hardware optimized for fast matrix multiplication, such as GPUs (Graphics Processing Units), is most suitable for implementing AI and ML because it can handle the parallel processing required for these operations efficiently.

C. High powered CPUs.

High powered CPUs are beneficial for general-purpose computing tasks and some aspects of ML, but they are not as efficient as specialized hardware like GPUs for matrix multiplication and other ML-specific tasks.

D. Hardware supporting high precision floating point operations.

High precision floating point operations are important for scientific computing and some specific AI tasks, but for many ML applications, fast matrix multiplication is more critical than high precision alone.

Therefore, the correct answer isBbecause hardware supporting fast matrix multiplication, such as GPUs, is most suitable for the parallel processing requirements of machine learning​​.

A. Add 10% of the rows randomly and create another model and compare the R-Square scores of both the models.

Adding more data to the training set can affect the R-Square score, but it does not directly verify the correctness of the implementation.

B. Train various models by changing the order of input features and verify that the R-Square score of these models vary significantly.

Changing the order of input features should not significantly affect the R-Square score if the implementation is correct, but this approach is more about testing model robustness rather than correctness of the implementation.

C. Compare the R-Square score of the model obtained using two different implementations that utilize two different programming languages while using the same algorithm and the same training and testing data.

This approach directly compares the performance of two implementations of the same algorithm. If both implementations produce similar R-Square scores on the same training and testing data, it suggests that the new implementation "X" is correct.

D. Drop 10% of the rows randomly and create another model and compare the R-Square scores of both the models.

Dropping data can lead to variations in the R-Square score but does not directly verify the correctness of the implementation.

Therefore, optionCis the most appropriate strategy because it directly compares the performance of the new implementation "X" with another implementation using the same algorithm and datasets, which helps in verifying the correctness of the implementation​​.

A. Black box attacks based on adversarial examples create an exact duplicate model of the original.

Black box attacks do not create an exact duplicate model. Instead, they exploit the model by querying it and using the outputs to craft adversarial examples without knowledge of the internal workings.

B. These attack examples cause a model to predict the correct class with slightly less accuracy even though they look like the original image.

Adversarial examples typically cause the model to predict the incorrect class rather than just reducing accuracy. These examples are designed to be visually indistinguishable from the original image but lead to incorrect classifications.

C. These attacks can't be prevented by retraining the model with these examples augmented to the training data.

This statement is incorrect because retraining the model with adversarial examples included in the training data can help the model learn to resist such attacks, a technique known as adversarial training.

D. These examples are model specific and are not likely to cause another model trained on the same task to fail.

Adversarial examples are often model-specific, meaning that they exploit the specific weaknesses of a particular model. While some adversarial examples might transfer between models, many are tailored to the specific model they were generated for and may not affect other models trained on the same task.

Therefore, the correct answer isDbecause adversarial examples are typically model-specific and may not cause another model trained on the same task to fail​​.